THAI NGUYEN UNIVERSITY
UNIVERSITY OF AGRICULTURE AND FORESTRY
NGUYEN THI YEN
THE ANALYSIS OF TOTAL PRECIPITABLE WATER FROM SATELLITE
AND MODEL DATA IN VIET NAM FROM 2008 TO 2017
BACHELOR THESIS
Study Mode: Full-time
Major: Environmental Science and Management
Faculty: Advanced Education Program Office
Batch: 2014-2018
Thai Nguyen, 15/08/2018
Thai Nguyen University of Agriculture and Forestry
Degree Program
Bachelor of Environmental Science and Management
Student name
Nguyen Thi Yen
Student ID
DTN1453110167
Thesis Title
The Analysis Of Total Precipitable Water From
Satellite And Model Data In Viet Nam From 2008 To
2017
Supervisor(s)
Prof. Dr. Chian-Yi Liu National Central University,
Taiwan.
Assoc.Prof. Dr. Tran Quoc Hung - Thai Nguyen University
Signature
of Agriculture and Forestry, Vietnam.
Abstract: ERA‐Interim is the latest global atmospheric reanalysis produced by
the European Centre for Medium‐Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF).
Atmospheric water vapor from reanalysis provides better spatiotemporal
resolution for longer period of time compare to satellite. Reanalysis data is the
product of numerical weather prediction model whereas satellite data is satellite
onboard instrumental data. In difference subplot in Vietnam have variety of
topography and difference amount of annual rainfall, those are two factors that
directly affect the flood situation in Vietnam, especially in recently years, this
situation is more and more complex. To study the climate in smaller spatial
resolution over this complex topographic region, the water vapor measurement
i
is important. We compared atmospheric total precipitable
data from
Atmospheric infrared sounder (AIRS) of Aqua satellite with European Centre
for Medium‐Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF: ERA model estimation-a
reanalysis model) over region within latitude interval 5ºN - 25ºN and longitude
interval 100ºE - 120ºE and four sub regions in Vietnam from 2008 to 2017.
This study has been conducted in order to see which of the dataset captures the
topographic and climate impact on water vapor content of the region in better
way. The thesis indicates that AIRS data maybe consider better than ERA
model estimated value for total precipitable water over the considered region.
Keywords
TPW,TCWV, ERA-model estimation, AIRS measurement
Number of pages
54
Date of
25th September, 2018
submission
ii
ACKNOWLEAGEMENT
Foremost, I would like to say thanks to the cooperation between Thai Nguyen
University of Agriculture and Forestry and National Central University for
providing me an amazing opportunity to internship in Taiwan. It brings me great
pleasure to work and submit my thesis for graduation.
I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my advisor Prof. Dr. Chian-Yi
Liu for the continuous support of my thesis, for his patience, motivation, enthusiasm,
and immense knowledge. His guidance helped me in all the time of research and
writing of this thesis. I could not have imagined having a better advisor and mentor for
my bachelor thesis. His willingness to give his time so generously to help me finishing
my internship in Taiwan.
I sincerely thanks to Assoc.Prof. Dr. Tran Quoc Hung for his patient
guidance, enthusiastic encouragement and useful critiques of this research work and
after I went to Taiwan, helping me to understand and complete proposal and thesis.
I would also like to thank the experts who were involved in the validation
survey for this research project: Mr. Chi-Hao Chiu and Ms. Tran Huyen Trang.
Without their passionate participation and input, the validation survey could not have
been successfully conducted.
I am really fortunate to be in Prof. Dr. Chian-Yi Liu’s lab. Thanks to all the
members in Professor Chian-Yi Liu’s laboratory who hearty help me a lot when I
work in there.
I also thank to my family for providing me emotional, unceasing
encouragement and physical and financial support. At last, I would like to thank all
ii
those other persons who helped me in completing this report. Because of my lack
knowledge, the mistake is inevitable, I am very grateful if I receive the comments and
opinions from teachers and others to contribute my report.
Sincerely,
Nguyen Thi Yen
iii
TABLE OF CONTENT
PART I: INTRODUCTION .........................................................................................1
1.1. Research rationale ....................................................................................................1
1.2. Research objective ....................................................................................................2
1.3. The question .............................................................................................................2
1.4. The significant of the thesis ......................................................................................2
1.5. Limitations ................................................................................................................3
PART II. REVIEW OF LITERATURE .....................................................................4
2.1. Total Precipitable water ............................................................................................4
2.1.1. Water vapor ...........................................................................................................4
2.1.2. Total precipitable water .........................................................................................6
2.2. Model and Satellite data ...........................................................................................7
2.2.1. ECMWF-Interim Daily (model data) ....................................................................7
2.2.2. AIRS data (satellite data).......................................................................................9
2.3. MATLAB software ................................................................................................12
PART III. METHODOLOGY ...................................................................................15
3.1. Study Frame work ..................................................................................................15
3.2. Description of the study area ..................................................................................15
3.2.1. South East Asia....................................................................................................16
3.2.2. Four sub regions ..................................................................................................16
3.3. Data collection ........................................................................................................18
3.3.1. Model Data collection (ERA-data) ......................................................................18
3.3.2. Satellite data collection (AIRS data) ...................................................................19
iv
3.4. Data analysis ...........................................................................................................21
PART IV. RESULT .....................................................................................................24
4.1. The difference between AIRS measured and ERA model estimated monthly TPW
in four sub regions. ........................................................................................................24
4.1.1. Northwest region. ................................................................................................24
4.1.2. Central Highlands region. ....................................................................................28
4.1.3. Hoang Sa archipelagoes ......................................................................................32
4.1.4 Mekong Delta region ............................................................................................35
4.1.5. ERA model estimated and AIRS measured monthly total precipitable water ....38
4.2. The difference between AIRS measured and ERA model estimated in study region
and four seasons.............................................................................................................39
4.2.1. General information.............................................................................................39
4.2.2. The difference between AIRS measured and ERA model estimated in study region 41
4.2.3. The difference between AIRS measured and ERA model estimated in difference
season.............................................................................................................................43
PART 5: DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION.........................................................46
5.1. Discussion………………………………………………………………………...46
5.2 Conclusion ...............................................................................................................48
REFERENCES ............................................................................................................50
v
LIST OF TABLES
Table 4.1. ERA model estimated monthly data of TPW over Northwest .....................26
region (kgm-2) ................................................................................................................26
Table 4.2. AIRS measured monthly data of TPW over Northwest region (kgm-2).......27
Table 4.3. ERA model estimated monthly data of TPW over Central Highlands ........30
region (kgm-2) ................................................................................................................30
Table 4.4. AIRS measured monthly data of TPW over Central Highlands region .......31
(kgm-2) ...........................................................................................................................31
Table 4.5. ERA model estimated monthly data of TPW over Hoang Sa archipelagoes
region (kgm-2) ................................................................................................................33
Table 4.6. AIRS measured monthly data of TPW over Hoang Sa archipelagoes region
(kgm-2) ...........................................................................................................................34
Table 4.7. ERA model estimated monthly data of TPW over Mekong Delta region
(kgm-2) ...........................................................................................................................36
Table 4.8. AIRS measured monthly data of TPW over Mekong Delta region .............37
Table 4.9. ERA model estimation monthly data of TPW over study region ................41
(kgm-2). ..........................................................................................................................41
Table 4.10. AIRS measurement monthly data of TPW over study region (kgm-2).......42
Table 4.11. ERA model estimation and AIRS measurement of TPW in 4 seasons in
study region (kgm-2). .....................................................................................................43
vi
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 3.1. Study Frame work .......................................................................................15
Figure 3.2. Study Region within latitude interval 5ºN - 25ºN and longitude interval
100ºE - 120ºE and Four Sub regions (From Google Earth) ..........................................16
Figure 3.3. North West of Vietnam within latitude interval 21º15´N-22º30´N and
longitude interval 103º30´E- 104º45´E (From Google Earth).......................................16
Figure 3.4. High Land of Vietnam within latitude interval 12º30´N - 14º15´N and
longitude interval 107º45´E - 108º45´E (From Google Earth)......................................17
Figure 3.5. Hoang Sa Archipelagoes of Vietnam within latitude interval 15º45´N 17º00´N and longitude interval 111º15´E - 113º00´E (From Google Earth) ................17
Figure 3.6. Mekong River Delta of Vietnam within latitude interval 9º30´N - 10º45´N
and longitude interval 105º30´E - 106º30´E (From Google Earth) ...............................18
vii
Abbreviations
AIRS
: Atmospheric Infrared Sounder
CC
: Correlation coefficient
ECMWF
: European Center for Medium-range Weather Forecasts
MATLAB : MATrix LABoratory
PWV
: Precipitable water vapor
rmse
: Root mean square error
TCWV
: Total column water vapor
TPW
: Total precipitable water
viii
PART I: INTRODUCTION
1.1. Research rationale
Precipitable water is the amount of water potentially available in the atmosphere
for precipitation, usually measured in a vertical column that extends from the Earth's
surface to the upper edge of the troposphere (Encyclopedia of Soils in the
Environment, 2005). Precipitable water in the atmosphere is an important climate
parameter, which is expected to increase with global mean sea surface temperature
(Liang, J., 2013). Frequent global determination of the distribution of total precipitable
water vapor is important to increase the understanding of the hydrological cycle,
biosphere-atmosphere interactions, the energy budget, and for monitoring climate
change due to the greenhouse gases (Encyclopedia of Soils in the Environment, 2005).
In addition, Precipitable Water Vapor (PWV) plays an important role in weather
forecasting. It is helpful in evaluating the changes of the weather system via observing
the distribution of water vapor (Yeh, T.-K., Shih et. al., 2018). Therefore, accurate
predictions of total precipitable water are extremely important in weather forecasting.
Total precipitable water data are generally derived from radiosonde measurement,
satellite remote sensing and reanalysis models. However, the accuracy of the two
methods will vary in each terrain, so it is important to compare satellite measured and
model estimated total precipitable water.
Vietnam - a country located in Southeast Asia, has a relatively large area
covering land and territorial waters in the South China Sea, including many islands
and Archipelagoes (Phạm Hoàng Hải. Nguyễn Thượng Hùng Nguyễn Ngọc Khánh,
1997). Vietnam, with its long terrain features along the longitude and the coastal, will
1
have a larger amount of total precipitable water in the air. Therefore estimating the
amount of precipitable water vapor in Vietnam is extremely important in predict the
weather. It was a vital role to conduct research “The Analysis of Total Precipitable
Water from Satellite and Model Data in Viet Nam from 2008 to 2017”
1.2. Research objective
- Compare atmospheric Total Precipitable Water content data from
Atmospheric infrared sounder (AIRS) and European Centre for Medium-Range
Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) in Viet Nam and nearby region.
- To assess which of the dataset captures the topographic and climatic impact on
water vapor content of the study region in a better way.
1.3. Research questions
- How are satellite data and model data different?
- Which dataset is better to use for TPW?
1.4. The significant of the thesis
- For learning and researching purpose:
+ Thesis will be the bridge between knowledge studying and practices, the
access to reality to better understand the nature of the problem.
+ Through the thesis, I knew how to use Mat lab software to mapping data and
analyzing data and practice.
-The practical significance:
+ Applying the knowledge on reality combined with collecting and analyzing
data make the most accurate predictions about the weather as well as the effect of
global warming in the study area.
2
+ It is also important for identifying where in Vietnam has the strongest impact
from climate change.
1.5. Limitations
Because the time for an internship was too short, this research project cannot
perform any other comparison.
3
PART II. REVIEW OF LITERATURE
2.1. Total Precipitable water
2.1.1. Water vapor
a) Definition of water vapor
Water vapor, water vapor or aqueous vapor, is the gaseous phase of water. It is
one state of water within the hydrosphere. Water vapor can be produced from the
evaporation or boiling of liquid water or from the sublimation of ice. Unlike other
forms of water, water vapor is invisible (What is water vapor?, 2018). Under typical
atmospheric conditions, water vapor is continuously generated by evaporation and
removed by condensation. It is lighter than air and triggers convection currents that
can lead to clouds (Water vapor, 2018, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_vapor).
Water vapor is not visible, therefore clouds, fog and most other formations
within the atmosphere that can be seen by the naked eye are not water vapor. Water
vapor, however, can be sensed. If enough of it is in the air it is felt as humidity. Water
vapor is one state of the water cycle within the hydrosphere. Water vapor can be
produced from the evaporation of liquid water or from the sublimation of ice. Under
normal atmospheric conditions, water vapor is continuously generated by evaporation
and removed by condensation.
Being a component of Earth's hydrosphere and hydrologic cycle, it is
particularly abundant in Earth's atmosphere where it is also a potent greenhouse gas
along with other gases such as carbon dioxide and methane (Water vapor, 2018,
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_vapor).
4
Water vapor is a relatively common atmospheric constituent, present even in the
solar atmosphere as well as every planet in the Solar System and many astronomical
objects including natural satellites, comets and even large asteroids (Water vapor,
2018,https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_vapor).
b) The important of water vapor
- Water vapor is vital to weather and climate as clouds, rain and snow have their
source in water vapor. All of the water vapor that evaporates from the surface of the
Earth eventually returns as precipitation - rain or snow. Water vapor is also the Earth's
most important greenhouse gas, giving us over 90% of the Earth's natural greenhouse
effect, which helps keep the Earth warm enough to support life. When liquid water is
evaporated to form water vapor, heat is absorbed. This helps to cool the surface of the
Earth. This "latent heat of condensation" is released again when the water vapor
condenses to form cloud water. This source of heat helps drive the updrafts in clouds
and precipitation systems. In order to understand water vapor, some insight must be
given into water (Claudette Ojo., Haloe v2.0 upper tropospheric water vapor
climatology)
- Water vapor is the dominant greenhouse gas, the most important gaseous
source of infrared opacity in the atmosphere (Held, I. M., & Soden, B. J. 2000). For
instance, the predicted global warming due to a CO2 doubling with water vapor
feedback is approximately twice the warming predicted without feedback (the socalled fixed relative humidity assumption of Manabe and Wetherald 1967). The
distribution of water vapor, its transport, and divergence are also essential ingredients
to our understanding of the distribution of solid and liquid water in the atmosphere and
5
therefore crucial to the significant and perplexing problem of cloud feedback to
climate change (Graeme L. Stephens, June 1990).
- Water vapor is also important to other physical processes that occur in the
atmosphere. Water vapor plays a decisive role in the transfer of radiation through the
atmosphere and it is important to the transport and release of latent heat (Stephens, G.
L.,1990).
- The role of water vapor in the atmosphere: water vapor plays a dominant role
in the radiative balance and the hydrological cycle. It is a principal element in the
thermodynamics of the atmosphere, it transports latent heat, it contributes to
absorption and emission in a n umber of bands and it condenses into clouds that reflect
and adsorb solar radiation, thus directly affecting the energy balance (Jacob, D., 2001).
2.1.2. Total precipitable water
Precipitable water is the amount of water potentially available in the
atmosphere for precipitation, usually measured in a vertical column that extends from
the Earth's surface to the upper edge of the troposphere (Encyclopedia of Soils in the
Environment, 2005). Precipitable water vapor (PWV) is an important climate
parameter indicative of available moisture in the atmosphere; it is also an important
greenhouse gas (Falaiye, O. A., Abimbola, O. J., Pinker, R. T., Pérez-Ramírez, D., &
Willoughby, A. A. 2018). The total water vapor contained in a vertical column of
atmosphere – from the surface of the earth to the end point of water vapor in the
atmosphere which has potential to precipitate, is called precipitable water vapor
(PWV). PWV can be measured in different ways, from ground-based to space-borne
instruments (Bayat, A., & Mashhadizadeh Maleki, S. 2018).
6
Precipitable water in the atmosphere is an important climate parameter, which is
expected to increase with global mean sea surface temperature (Jinyou Liang, in
Chemical Modeling for Air Resources, 2013). Precipitable water vapor over oceans
represents the main components of the landatmosphere-ocean ecosystem and plays an
important role in the exchange of substances and the radiative balance on the global
scale (Gong, S., 2018). Precipitable water vapor (PWV) over the oceans represent
important components in the atmosphere and they also produce clouds and
precipitation, which play a key role in weather and climate changes (Soden, B. J., &
Lanzante, J. R. 1996)and( Xu, X., & Wang, J. 2015). In addition, as the main
components in the land-atmosphere-ocean ecosystem, PWV affect the radiative
balance directly and indirectly on a global scale and further have an impact on changes
in the environment and the climate (Ichoku, C. 2002).
2.2. Model and Satellite data
2.2.1. ECMWF-Interim Daily (model data)
ERA‐Interim is the latest global atmospheric reanalysis produced by the
European Centre for Medium‐Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF). The ERA‐Interim
project was conducted in part to prepare for a new atmospheric reanalysis to replace
ERA‐40, which will extend back to the early part of the twentieth century. ERAInterim covers the period from 1 January 1989 onwards, and continues to be extended
forward in near-real time (Dee, D. P. et. al, 2011). An extension from 1979 to 1989 is
currently in preparation. Gridded data products include a large variety of 3 -hourly
surface parameters, describing weather as well as ocean-wave and land-surface
conditions, and 6-hourly upper-air parameters covering the troposphere and
7
stratosphere. Vertical integrals of atmospheric fluxes, monthly averages for many of
the parameters, and other derived fields have also been produced. Berrisford et al.
(2009) provide a detailed description of the ERA-Interim product archive. Information
about the current status of ERA-Interim production, availability of data online, and
near-real-time updates of various climate indicators derived from ERA-Interim data,
can be found at http://www.ecmwf.int/research/era.
The ERA-Interim reanalysis is produced with a sequential data assimilation
scheme, advancing forward in time using 12-hourly analysis cycles. In each cycle,
available observations are combined with prior information from a forecast model to
estimate the evolving state of the global atmosphere and its underlying surface. This
involves computing a variational analysis of the basic upper-air atmospheric fields
(temperature, wind, humidity, ozone, surface pressure), followed by separate analyses
of near-surface parameters (2m temperature and 2m humidity), soil moisture and soil
temperature, snow, and ocean waves. The analyses are then used to initialise a shortrange model forecast, which provides the prior state estimates needed for the next
analysis cycle (Dee, D. P. et. al, 2011).
The forecast model has a crucial role in the data assimilation process. Use of the
model equations makes it possible to extrapolate information from locally observed
parameters to unobserved parameters in a physically meaningful way, and also to carry
this information forward in time. The skill and accuracy of the forecast model
determines how well the assimilated information can be retained; better forecasts mean
that smaller adjustments are needed to maintain consistency with observations as
time evolves.
8
Additionally, while producing a forecast, the model estimates a wide variety of
physical parameters such as precipitation, turbulent fluxes, radiation fields, cloud
properties, soil moisture, etc. Even if not directly observed, these are constrained by
the observations used to initialize the forecast. The accuracy of these model-generated
estimates naturally depends on the quality of the model physics as well as that of the
analysis (Dee, D. P. et. al, 2011).
2.2.2. AIRS data (satellite data)
AIRS data is distributed by the NASA Goddard Earth Sciences Data
Information and Services Center (GESDISC). Launched aboard the NASA Earth
Observing System satellite called "Aqua" in 2002, the Atmospheric Infrared Sounder
(AIRS) instrument suite constitutes an innovative space borne atmospheric sounding
system comprised of the AIRS hyper spectral infrared instrument and two
multichannel microwave instruments the Advanced Microwave Sounding Unit
(AMSU-A) and the Humidity Sounder for Brazil (HSB). Together these instruments
observe global water and energy cycles, climate variation and trends, and the response
of the climate system to increased greenhouse gases (AIRS atmospheric infrared
sounder, https://airs.jpl.nasa.gov/data/overview).
AIRS retrieved data products provide a daily global view of the threedimensional physical state of the atmosphere (air temperature, water vapor, clouds)
and the distribution of trace gas constituents (ozone, carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide
and methane) (AIRS atmospheric infrared sounder) .
The AIRS instrument suite consisting of the hyperspectral (2378 infrared
channels and 4 visible/near-infrared channels) AIRS instrument, the (15 microwave
9
channel) AMSU-A instrument and the (4 microwave channel) HSB instrument was
launched aboard NASA's Aqua Earth Observing System satellite on May 4, 2002. The
advantage of the AIRS suite in orbit is the provision of rapid global coverage as
radiosonde coverage of much of Earth's land mass and all but a few locations in the
oceans is practically nonexistent. There are less than 1000 radiosonde launch sites
worldwide, most based in Europe and North America and most launch two
radiosondes per day. AIRS soundings are equivalent to launching 300,000 radiosondes
on a 50 km grid over the globe each day (AIRS atmospheric infrared sounder,
https://airs.jpl.nasa.gov/data/overview).
The orbit of the Aqua satellite is polar sun-synchronous with a nominal altitude
of 705 kilometers (438 miles) and an orbital period of 98.8 minutes, completing
approximately 14.5 orbits per day. The repeat cycle period is 233 orbits (16 days) with
a ground track repeatability of ± 20 kilometers (12 miles). The satellite equatorial
crossing local times are 1:30 a.m. in a descending orbit and 1:30 p.m. in an
ascending orbit.
The AIRS instrument suite was constructed to obtain atmospheric temperature
profiles to an accuracy of 1 kelvin for every 1 kilometer layer in the troposphere and
an accuracy of 1 kelvin for every 4 kilometer layer in the stratosphere up to an altitude
of 40 kilometers. The temperature profile accuracy in the troposphere matches that
achieved by radiosondes launched from ground stations. The advantage of the AIRS
suite in orbit is the provision of rapid global coverage as radiosonde coverage of
Earth's oceans is practically nonexistent (AIRS atmospheric infrared sounder,
https://airs.jpl.nasa.gov/data/overview).
10
- Xem thêm -