March 22, 2012
A Penton Media Publication
Tune in to EngineeringTV.com
RADIOS IN SPACE: SDRs
FOR THE SPACE STATION,
page 20
WILL ALUMINUM
ION BATTERIES MAKE
LITHIUMION OBSOLETE?
page 38
A GLIMPSE OF THE
FUTURE THROUGH
CONCEPT CARS, page 44
ENGINEERING FOR THE
OTHER 90%, page 52
RS# 101
&
' (
RS# 102
!
!
"#
$
!
% !
&
!
%
!
'
!
(
!
! )
!
"
#
$ %
) * $
(
+
+ ! +
VOLUME 84
ISSUE 4
MARCH 22, 2012
AUTOMOTIVE
Concept cars 2012:
Chevrolet Tru 140S
A glimpse of the future
Whether consumers want ecoconscious electric cars, gasburning performance or economy,
or a hybrid of the
two, the world’s
automakers
seem ready to
build it.
FEATURES
Scion FR-S
Chevrolet
Code 130R
Authored by:
This year’s Detroit Auto Show featured several concept
cars, everything from micromini pickups to flashy highperformance hybrids. There was also a good mix of powertrains showcased, including several all-electric cars and
vans and a wide variety of hybrids. And conventional
gas-powered concepts also held their own.
Conventional engines
20
NASA payload will test
software-defined radios
Space Communication
and Navigation Testbed will
communicate with both Earth
and space-bound radios.
The low, sleek FR-S (front-engine, rear-wheel-drive)
sport car from Scion could help you forget the boxy designs the company is known for. It carries a 200-hp, 2-liter
boxer engine mounted in front, but lower and farther back
than other front-engine cars. This gives the concept car
a lower center of gravity and a front-to-rear weight ratio
conducive to good handling and dynamics. The engine
uses direct and port injection for more power — 200 hp —
as well as more torque throughout the powerband without
sacrificing fuel economy. The flat four mates to a six-speed
manual or automatic transmission.
Chevrolet is looking to connect with car buyers under
the age of 30, hoping to tap into some of their estimated
$1 trillion in purchasing power. One concept car they
have designed with the younger buyers in mind is the
Code 130R, a four-seat coupe. It features a 1.4-liter turbocharged EcoTec engine that can crank out 150 hp or
148 lb-ft of torque, and still get 40 mpg (highway). The car
also uses eAssist, a combination of features that include
shutting off the engine at stops, regenerative braking, and
44
MACHINE DESIGN.com
smoothing torque during accelerations. These features
should help balance turbocharged performance with fuel
economy.
The other youth-targeted concept car from Chevy
is the Tru 140S, a streamlined front-wheel-drive sports
coupe. The four-seat, three-door hatchback is based on the
same platform as the Cruze and Volt. It carries the same
engine and powertrain features as the Code 130R.
Chevy plans to market both of these cars soon and
with the features young
car buyers say they want.
This includes a price tag
under $20k, fuel economy of at least 40 mpg, as
well Wi-Fi, smartphone
integration, a headsup display, and Chevy’s
MyLink connectivity.
To get this audience’s
opinions on what the interior and dashboard
should look like, Chevy
will take the cars to several major auto shows,
key lifestyle events such
as concerts and festivals,
and college campuses.
There, t he y wi l l us e
MARCH 22, 2012
kiosks and other social media to gather opinions and suggestions.
The MKZ concept car is the next step in the reinvention of Lincoln, according to that company’s Vice President of Global Product Development, Derrick
Katz. Though clearly conservative in design, the MKZ does feature a glass roof
that stretches from the windshield back to the rear window and from the left
roof rail to the right rail, The four-door, four-seat sedan can be equipped with
a variety of front or rear-wheel-drive engines. Many auto observers believe that
when the MKZ comes to the showrooms, it will carry a 300-hp, 3.7-liter engine, the same one found in the MKS. It might also have an optional twin-turbo
3.6-liter EcoBoost V6 with about
355 hp. And a hybrid version is also
a possibility.
The car boasts a continuously
controlled damping suspension,
which is driver adjustable, and Ford’s
lane-keeping subsystem that alerts
drivers when the vehicle strays from
its lane. And in a retro touch, the car’s
Lincoln
automatic transmission is controlled
MKZ
using pushbuttons.
Hybrids
The NS4 from Toyota uses a nextgeneration plug-in hybrid drive,
which should get better acceleration, longer all-electric range, shorter
charging times, and be smaller and
lighter, compared to the current Prius
MARCH 22, 2012
44
to lithium-ion
38 Goodbye
batteries?
Aluminum is cheap, easy to
find, and can be used to devise
batteries having a higher energy
density than that from lithiumion batteries.
44
ELECTRICAL/ELECTRONIC
Goodbye to
Inexpensive
aluminum may
hold the key to
battery chemistries
that pack more
punch than today’s
lithium-ion cells.
Concept cars 2012:
A glimpse of the future
Here’s a look at what the automotive
industry is planning for the future.
lithium-ion
batteries?
Authored by:
Leland Teschler
Editor
[email protected]
Resources
Cornell University, Energy Materials Center,
http://www.emc2.cornell.edu/news/story/
Science%20news.html
Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Aluminum
Battery Research, http://www.ornl.gov/adm/
partnerships/events/presentations/spark_
aluminum_ion_battery.pdf
For more info on lithiumion batteries, scan this
code or go to: http://
machinedesign.com/
article/lithium-ionbatteries-get-a-boostfrom-novel-materials-1103
Back to the future?
52 Designing for places that
38
can’t afford high tech.
MACHINE DESIGN.com
A piece of aluminum has more free energy content than
the same amount of either methanol or ethanol. That,
succinctly, explains why scientists are now trying to perfect batteries based on chemistry that involves aluminum.
Even better, aluminum-ion batteries promise to squeeze
more energy into a given space than the lithium-ion batteries that seem to be in the headlines these days for all
the wrong reasons.
Aluminum is the most abundant metallic element and
the third most abundant of all elements on the planet.
Most of the countries that mine the bauxite ore from
whence it comes are friendly to the U. S. And the metal’s
abundance brings the promise of aluminum-based batteries that are relatively cheap.
The key quality of aluminum that makes it advantageous in battery chemistry is the fact that it is trivalent,
having three valence electrons involved in forming valence
bonds. Lithium, in contrast, has one valence electron. The
result is that battery charge/discharge reactions (per formula unit) involving aluminum transfer three electrons
compared with only one with lithium. So an aluminumbased battery can be smaller than a lithium-ion cell packing the same power: Aluminum-based batteries have a
potential energy density of 1,060 W-hr/kg compared with
406 W-hr/kg for those based on lithium ion.
Problem is, there are a number of obstacles that have
made it tough to devise a practical aluminum-battery
chemistry. For one thing, aluminum batteries typically use
an aqueous electrolyte and consume water during their
discharge cycle. They also give off hydrogen. This behavior has made it impossible to come up with an aluminumbased battery that could be sealed. And aluminum used
in the battery anode typically corrodes or forms an oxide
film. Both factors reduce the efficiency of battery reactions over time. Unfortunately, these effects can take place
so quickly that commercial batteries based on aluminum
have been impractical for most applications.
MARCH 22, 2012
38
Access our Reader Service
Web site to quickly find and
request information on the
products and services found
in the pages of MACHINE DESIGN.
www.machinedesign.com/rsc
2
MACHINE DESIGN.com
MARCH 22, 2012
Stephen J. Mraz
Senior Editor
[email protected]
Resources:
Acura, http://tinyurl.com/76emwt6
BMW, http://tinyurl.com/7mrc2nn
Chevrolet, http://tinyurl.com/88wdrvd
Infiniti, http://tinyurl.com/mmao8n
Lexus, http://tinyurl.com/7oy3zdz
Lincoln, www.lincoln.com
Nissan, www.env200.com
Scion, http://tinyurl.com/7fhzzct
Smart car, www.smartusa.com
Toyota Motor Sales USA, http://tinyurl.
com/7qd5zuy
Volkswagen of America, http://tinyurl.
com/7tphnon
For a look at some of our
past features on concept
cars, scan this code or go
to: http://machinedesign.
com/article/conceptcars-over-the-past-tenyears-0331
MACHINE DESIGN.com
45
tick tock
Less downtime with every valve.
Power. Precision.
Performance.
Continental Hydraulics knows that time is money, that’s why we offer a
complete line of Proportional Directional Valves with integrated digital
electronics for maximum precision, durability and reduced hysteresis.
Our high performance valves are available in all standard NFPA mounting
patterns and flow ranges. The on-board microprocessor provides fast
response times, seamless interchangeability among valves and supports
software-based, hydraulic parameter modifications to ensure optimal
load movement. Factory calibrated for time-savings, output range
assurance and easy valve-to-valve exchange, our proportional valves
offer a smooth, shock-less motion and precise position control to reduce
down time, increase production rates and make every second count.
RS# 103
PUMPS
VALVES
POWER UNITS
952. 895. 6400 | www.continentalhydraulics.com
ON THE COVER
DEPARTMENTS
The e-NV200, Nissan’s allelectric concept van.
8 EDITORIAL
A Nobel Prize for … engineers?
Editorial content is indexed in the Applied Science
Technology Index, the Engineering Index, SciSearch
and Research Alert. Microfilm copies available from
National Archive Publishing Company (NAPC), 300
N. Zeeb Rd., P.O. Box 998, Ann Arbor, MI 48106-0998,
Ph: 734-302-6500 or 800-420-NAPC (6272), extension
6578.
10 EDITORIAL STAFF
12 LETTERS
16 SCANNING FOR IDEAS
Rugged CNC router is easy to use
Compressed gas keeps circuits cool
20 REPORTER’S NOTEBOOK
28 LOOKING BACK
35 COMMENTARY
Do we need a sustainability standard?
36 ADVANCED MANUFACTURING
Electron-beam melting builds titanium parts
58 ORR ON ENGINEERING
How secure is your job?
59 SOFTWARE PRODUCTS
60 PRODUCT SPOTLIGHT
62 PRODUCTS
66 DATA FILES
68 AD INDEX
69 BUSINESS INDEX
Subscription Policy: MACHINE DESIGN is circulated
to research, development, and design engineers
primarily engaged in the design and manufacture
of machinery, electrical/electronic equipment, and
mechanical equipment. To obtain a complimentary
subscription see our Web page at submag.com/sub/
mn. For change of address fill out a new qualification
form at submag.com/sub/mn.
Printed in U.S.A., Copyright © 2012. Penton Media, Inc.
All rights reserved. MACHINE DESIGN (ISSN 0024-9114)
is published semimonthly except for a single issue
in January, February, June, July, and December by
Penton Media, Inc., 9800 Metcalf Ave., Overland Park,
KS 66212.
Can GST #R126431964. Canadian Post Publications
Mail Agreement No.40612608. Canada return address:
Pitney Bowes, P.O. Box 25542, London, Ont., N6C 6B2.
70 BUSINESS STAFF
Digital subscription rates: U.S.: one year, $69; two
years, $99;. Canada/Mexico: one year, $79; two years,
$119; All other countries: one year, $99; two years,
$149.
71 BACKTALK
MACHINE DESIGN.com
Permission to photocopy is granted for users
registered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC)
Inc. to photocopy any article, with the exception of
those for which separate ownership is indicated on
the first page of the article, provided that the base fee
of $1.25 per copy of the article, plus $.60 per page is
paid to CCC, 222 Rosewood Dr., Danvers, MA 01923
(Code No. 0024-9114/12 $1.25 + .60).
Paid subscriptions include issues 1-18. Issue No. 19
(OEM Handbook and Supplier Directory) is available at
additional cost. Rates: U.S.: one year, $139; two years,
$199;. Canada/Mexico: one year, $159; two years, $239;
All other countries: one year, $199; two years, $299. Cost
for back issues are U.S. $10.00 per copy plus tax, Canada
$15.00 per issue plus tax, and Int’l $20.00 per issue.
Product Locator, $50.00 plus tax. Prepaid subscription:
Penton Media (MACHINE DESIGN), P.O. Box 2100, Skokie
IL 60076-7800. Periodicals Postage Paid at Shawnee
Mission, Kans., and at additional mailing offices.
Enclosures
4
For customized article reprints and permissions
please contact: Penton Reprints, 1-888-858-8851,
e-mail at
[email protected] or visit
pentonreprints.com.
MARCH 22, 2012
POSTMASTER: Send change of address notice to
Customer Service, MACHINE DESIGN, P.O. Box 2100, Skokie,
IL 60076-7800.
No other controller can do this!
Use the technology built into the Productivity3000 programmable
controller to make your job easier. Don’t pay extra or take up
valuable rack space for communications modules. With its
industry-leading seven built-in communication ports, this CPU has
phenomenal cosmic power in an itty-bitty living space!
. !)#%!-$&
((%&$&""##"$#($&#
. !$!,%#'$#%$&()%($$)&($#!!$!& '
. %$&($&(!$#($&"$*!&*
.
((&"$(,%#'$#%$&((up to 32 remote racks plus 64 AC drives)
. '%
((%$&($&)%($"$&%#!'
%&($%&#)'#'''-'("#(+$& #)'#%$%)!&
%&$($$!'')'$)' $&'##"!'
.+$'&!%$&('$&%&%&!*#(&$&$#(&$!!&
#(+$& #*$)'$&)'($"
%&$($$!'
http://bit.ly/p3000
RS# 104
What’s new online machinedesign.com
Free Webcast: Understanding
permanent-magnet motor technology
March 22, 2012, 2:00 p. m. EST
Over the years, motor technology has changed to provide better capabilities
and performance, but no motor works for every application. Engineers are
continually forced to compare and contrast options to document benefits and
protect their projects from potential pitfalls. Leeson Electric is presenting a
condensed technical course on permanent-magnet motors to help engineers
assess that technology. Topics include: a technical overview of PM motors,
energy efficiency, power density, and control requirements, followed by a Q&A
session. The Webcast will also be archived for on-demand viewing. Learn more
at http://machinedesign.com/content/understanding-permanent-magnet-motortechnology-0302.
Jewel bearings
at
www.ia-na.com
September 10 - 15, 2012
McCormick Place,
Chicago, Illinois
For more information, please contact
Aryan Zandieh at (312) 924-1688 or
[email protected].
Organized by:
6
Partner:
MACHINE DESIGN.com
EDITOR’S WEB PICKS
Bearings made of synthetic ruby
or sapphire are exceptionally
hard and rugged. They run
with low friction, handle high
temperatures, and are chemically inert,
nonmagnetic, and surprisingly economical.
An expert from Bird Precision explains the
basics of jewel bearings and where they’re
best applied at
www.engineeringtv.com/video/
Jewel-Bearing-Performance-from;OnlyEngineering-TV-Videos.
MARCH 22, 2012
NPE microsite
Energy savings estimator
PolyOne’s NPE microsite (npe.
polyone.com) previews topics it will
feature at the NPE show, including
barrier technology, bioplasticizers,
trends in appliance and electronics
design, and sustainability. Users can
also schedule meetings at PolyOne’s
booth or request immediate technical advice on specific problems.
There’s also a free guest-pass registration area, live Twitter feed, and
blog.
Siemens Drive Technologies
Div. has an online Energy Savings
Estimator that lets users of drives,
motors, couplings, and gearboxes
estimate potential energy savings
across the entire drivetrain. Given
data on the application — horsepower, motor speeds, and gearbox
reduction ratios — the Estimator
evaluates potential savings and ROI
of the recommended upgrade. For
more info, visit www.usa.siemens.
com/energysavingsestimator.
Product catalog app
Bosch Rexroth’s GoTo Products
iPad App offers ready access to
product information in its print
catalogs, including technical data,
dimensions, and specification
tables on thousands of linear motion, hydraulic, pneumatic, electric
drive, and control products. It also
includes video clips and links to the
company’s Facebook page, Twitter
feeds, and YouTube channel. For
more information, visit www.
boschrexroth-us.com/gotoipadapp.
Automation eLearning
Omron Industrial Automation has
expanded its eLearning education
portal (www.omron247.com/elearning) with 10 introductory courses
in eight different languages on automating machines and processes.
Topics include an introduction
to factory automation, as well as
courses on general-purpose relays;
photoelectric, proximity, and fiberoptic sensors; power supplies; and
temperature controllers.
$$%+)+%#&$('%#'%*$),%'"$"*$
'!'""$2)%'))%%"())&%,'
&'%*)+).$$"%$#&%(("($(&)
)""$$)'(*")('$(&'$$,,%'!0%,
/$($#%'#&'((+($(%,)(.%*'
)*'$)%$'(.%*'($)#(&'%*)+).$
"'),%'!())%$&'%'#$(%$-)$')%$
($)!0)
3)6+*/(1+5+6,462'3)+2++87
79656/7/3-)478+,?)/+3)=;/8.
+11'3*$'1)91'8+=496
5'=(')05+6/4*847++;.'8
'*:'38'-+7';'/8=49
""'(%$1%'!())%$(,))")()'&(
#&%,'.%*')#)%,%'!,)%*)"#))%$(
ǩ%')$&'% )(*"(,)*&)% -()'
&'%'#$$(
ǩ
')/%'*'$)()").%$
&&")%$(
"!%"%'!($*)%(!$+$)%'
ǩ&)%$"""'%*&&%')1&'%+(
&%$((
)%%')#'$($%')(*&&%')$$+'%
#$*)(%'"((
#'-&+(&$'%-)'(&+*)/-*&$("*)*(
")')%&$'(&%.+(*!&%)*
,,,)*&( &$
"A'3*8.+(+3).2'603'2+":/+;5+6,A'6+6+-/78+6+*86'*+2'6074,8.+"8'3*'6*+6,462'3)+:'19'8/4346546'8/43
425+8/8/:+(+3).2'606+7918778'8+*'(4:+6+@+)86+7918759(1/7.+*43;;;75+)46-'74,9-978
8.
#.+)425'6/74356+
7+38+*'(4:+/7('7+*4378'3*'6*/3*9786=;46078'8/4376+56+7+38'8/:+4,;.+3+').5'68/)91'6-6'5./)7564*9)8;'71'93).+*33
!+74198/434,
<
%/3*4;7%/3
/8"=78+2
&>+246=3!+74198/434,
<
%/3&<
<>46+ 9'* &
468.+1'8+78":/+;5+6,A(+3).2'606+79187:/7/8;;;75+)46--;5-
B
$46546'8/43116/-.876+7+6:+*$8.+$14-4'297#+71''3* 9'*64'6+86'*+2'607'3*466+-/78+6+*
86'*+2'6074,$46546'8/4311)425'3='3*564*9)83'2+7'6+86'*+2'607466+-/78+6+*86'*+2'6074,8.+6+75+)8/:+4;3+67
;/8.;./).8.+='6+'774)/'8+*
RS# 105
EDITORIAL
A Nobel Prize for ...
engineers?
It is relatively easy to name a few big-name scientists off the top of your head.
It is nearly impossible for the average Joe or Jane to do the same for engineers.
No wonder, then, that engineers often complain that they get no respect
from the public. Surveys of public perception bear out this impression. A
Harris Poll in 2007 found that only 30% of Americans hold engineers in high
regard.
But a new competition aims to change all this. Called the Queen Elizabeth
Prize for Engineering, it will be run by the Royal Academy of Engineering.
The winner gets more than a bowling trophy. This contest will award £1 million to an engineer or group of engineers responsible for what judges feel
is the world’s greatest modern-engineering advancement which has had a
demonstrable benefit for humanity.
You might think of the Queen Elizabeth Prize as a Nobel Prize for engineers. That’s certainly the feeling you get from conversations with its judging
panel. “The Nobel has been about people who have generated knowledge that
has somehow improved human welfare,” says Professor Calestous Juma, an
international development expert with Harvard University and one of the
Prize judges. “But if somebody identifies the fact that you can kill a bacteria
using a compound, somebody else has to figure out how to actually make it
into a drug. The people who manufacture the drug are never honored, only
the people who came up with the idea. The Queen Elizabeth Prize honors
those who translate the ideas into practical solutions.”
The Queen Elizabeth Prize could put engineering on equal footing with
science, where many would argue it deserves to be. After all, several Nobelwinning achievements wouldn’t have been possible without engineering
achievements that preceded them. For example, says Juma, “We would not
have had advances in science without new observational instruments that
were developed by engineers.”
There are numerous engineering prizes today, but they lack visibility. In
contrast, Juma thinks the Queen Elizabeth Prize will help change the public
image of engineers to one of people who solve global problems. “Over the
past 50 years, there have been a lot of negative perceptions of engineering,”
he says. “When a dam breaks, people initially blame the dam and then blame
shifts to engineers. Environmentalists blame engineers for being the source
of environmental problems. So engineers are under enormous scrutiny and
must constantly defend their actions. But if you look at all the improvements
in human welfare, we are really reaping the benefits of engineers, people who
maintain and fix things.”
You might wonder how in the world Prize judges will be able to quantify
the “benefit to humanity” of specific entries that could conceivably range
from rocket engines to medical devices. That’s a good point, Juma admits.
“We are just getting started. If we got into a discussion about categories, it
would delay the whole thing by five years. The trust that runs the prize will
have to grapple with those kinds of questions,” he says.
Interestingly, Juma hopes the Prize will get the attention of young people
in particular. “Look at science fairs for school kids,” he says. “Though they’re
called science fairs, the exhibit tables usually display something constructed
as an engineering project. We want to help young people get to the point of
saying, ‘I want to go out and solve a practical problem and not just debate it.’”
—Leland Teschler, Editor
RS# 106
MARCH 22, 2012
Try Solid Edge for free!
Breakthrough 3D CAD software
siemens.com/plm/free-solid-edge
Now you can try a fully loaded version of Solid Edge
with synchronous technology free with no obligation.
Experience this state-of-the-art application and
discover how the power of synchronous technology
can have a significant impact on your engineering
productivity, design creativity and product quality.
This program also includes access to interactive
tutorials, video tips and a user forum to help you really
experience the power of Solid Edge.
Download Solid Edge now at siemens.com/plm/freesolid-edge or call 800-807-2200.
Solid Edge. Design better.
RS# 107
WASHERS &
STAMPINGS
EDITORIAL STAFF
EDITOR
Leland E. Teschler
leland.teschler@penton.com
MANAGING EDITOR
FREE CATALOG & BROCHURE
Kenneth J. Korane
ken.korane@penton.com
Call 1-888-WASHERS
SENIOR EDITORS
)($"( "'(!&%
)
Leslie Gordon
leslie.gordon@penton.com
Stephen J. Mraz
stephen.mraz@penton.com
ASSOCIATE EDITOR
WWW.BOKERS.COM/MD
Robert J. Repas, Jr.
robert.repas@penton.com
RS# 108
INDUSTRY COVERAGE
IBOCO is celebrating
25 years of innovation
Introducing IBOCO’s new full line catalog
AUTOMOTIVE, PACKAGING,
MEDICAL
Stephen J. Mraz
CAD/CAM, MANUFACTURING
Leslie Gordon
ELECTRICAL, ELECTRONICS
Robert J. Repas, Jr.
IBOCO’s 25th anniversary
catalog features more of
what you’ve come to expect,
from the industry leader:
· New products
· Unmatched service
· Value-added capabilities
FLUID POWER, MECHANICAL
Kenneth J. Korane
EDITORIAL PRODUCTION
Denise Greco
Editorial Production Manager
Randall L. Rubenking
Art Director
Call or email us today for your
copy of the newest innovations,
only from IBOCO.
&')!"#+%*."(&%
!&%
.-
www.iboco.com
$"#"&&"&&&$
RS# 109
1300 E. 9th St. Cleveland, OH 44114-1503
RS# 110
LETTERS
One more engineering
movie
I may be a bit late in responding
to the best engineering movies,
but one movie that should be included has to be “The World’s Fastest Indian.” It’s a classic tale of a
guy in New Zealand with nothing
more than garage-shop tools who
builds a motorcycle (including
the engine castings) that breaks
200 mph at Bonneville. Plus, he
was a self-taught engineer to
boot.
Jim Kovach
Praise and blame for the
patent system
Your editorial is interesting and informative, however there is a flip
side (“R&D doesn’t mean innovation,” Oct. 6). From a corporate
perspective, patents can and are
used as marketing tools and legal
weapons. However, at the other
end of the spectrum, the patent
system is also a doorway for the
“little guy” to take a chance and
develop a product without being
wiped out by major power players
in industry.
My own tale of getting a patent is one of 10 years of hard work,
so far. And any funds I could raise,
I put into R&D for the opportunity to bring a product to market
that is technologically ahead of
the current offerings in an industry dominated by a pair of behemoths. These companies are ruthless in their market dominance.
Without the patent system, small
entities and individuals such as
myself have no outlet for their inventiveness. So, although the big
players may misuse the system,
grass-roots innovation would certainly stagnate under the weight
of corporate power and market
domination without it.
Tony Lorger
Having obtained two patents in
the U. S. over the past 10 years, it
is my opinion that the patent office in the U. S., as well as those
in other countries, have been re12
MACHINE DESIGN.com
sponsible for a wave of “bad” patent releases. I do not know exactly
why this has happened, but it
seems many inventors, both corporate and individuals, have gotten patents on weak inventions
or have cut corners in the revision
process to generate tons of patent
releases with low-quality content
or even material that should have
never been patented.
I have heard this directly from
my patent agent, from other inventors, and from those involved
with patents. So now we’re stuck
with a lot of patents issued for
stuff that, when anyone looks at it,
says: “No way, this cannot be patented,“ But it is.
So the rightful owners of these
half-baked patents will use the full
extent of the law to protect their
intellectual property, even if they
kill streams of innovation in the
process, along with manufacturing jobs, a host of careers, and a
long list of suppliers.
We need business people, politicians, and inventors to demand
that the patent system be made
fair and workable and a powerful
driver of technology and business
once again. Just recently there
have been announcements about
tightening the patent rules and
supervision. This is a good start.
George Guillaume
The problem with eliminating
patents is that there is a class of
start-up businesses focused on
making totally new technologies
MARCH 22, 2012
that only makes business sense if
there are patents.
If there’s no way to prevent people (or corporations) from stealing
your technology, then you must
either be the only one using that
product, keep the details a trade
secret, or give up, because any
time you explain it to a competent
manufacturer, its managers will
just say: “Oh, we can do that,” and
you’re out of business.
Bryan Williams
Government versus
private-sector jobs
After seeing so many ups and
downs in the private sector, while
at the same time witnessing my
friends who opted to work for the
government (city, state or federal)
enjoy so much stability, I can’t
help but wonder if I made the
right choice going to the private
sector.
And it‘s not just the stability.
Government engineers also enjoy
very respectable wages, raises, retirement pensions, and vacations.
It may not be as glorified a position as in the private industry, but
in this day and age, what would
one rather have: the gold or the
glory?
Overall, however, the U. S. treats
engineers quite well, though Europe may be slightly better when
it comes to compensating engineers. But could this eventually
make our products too expensive
to be competitive in price? Mean-
Tough application,
ingenious solution
Exactly
Mastering challenges together — Rexroth makes it easy to implement automation.
Our many years’ experience in a wide range of industries has given us extensive application
knowledge. We offer this comprehensive understanding to the tasks you bring us, leading
to ingenious solutions.
Regardless of the drive technology used, we thought ahead and integrated intelligence
throughout. This consistency makes you more efficient — from planning to start-up and
daily operation. Your benefits are real: Increased productivity, improved energy efficiency
and maximum machine safety. You can count on Rexroth to have the appropriate drive and
control solution to meet your needs exactly.
Bosch Rexroth Corporation
www.boschrexroth-us.com
RS# 111
LETTERS
while, China and India have a definite edge in that they have a large,
well-educated population used
to low wages and benefits. They
can make the cheap widgets the
world is hungry for.
Syed M. Kadri
Where are our skilled
workers?
To answer the question your blog
asks, (“Why does the U. S. lack
skilled workers?,” Oct 13, From
Shop Floor to Software): Generations of American children have
been deprived of the commonsense curriculum that comes with
using your hands. Now it is up to
industry, or what remains of it,
to teach them what they did not
learn. But industry doesn’t know
what to do. They stopped serious
career training long ago.
The popular narrative must
change to embrace the accep-
tance of using one’s hands to create things. The people who want
to have gainful employment, doing something useful and valuable, will have to be convinced
that carving a horse or making
a mahogany lamp is a learning
experience. Shop class was not
carpentry prep; it was about common sense, critical thinking, making intelligent decisions, and using knowledge to create skill.
Bring back shop class if you
want a motivated, sharp, new
generation of technical people.
Pat Gallagher
The problem I am seeing is that
companies do not want to put
time into training people. I have
a B.S. in mechanical engineering
from Purdue and feel I am not
being given the chance to gain
experience. I have asked employers. “How do you get experience
if you do not want to give some-
one a chance?” This question then
gets dodged. Employers are also
quick to identify job applicants
as the problem and constantly
complain that they cannot find
skilled people.
But you are right in that the
schools have dumbed down the
math and sciences. This problem
must be addressed. People are
closing their eyes to a situation
they do not want to acknowledge.
It will not get better on its own.
Companies are going to have to
put time into people whether by
their own choice or by government force. If a person meets the
educational requirements of the
job, he or she should be given a
chance to gain experience. I am
tired of hearing employers cry
that they can’t find skilled people.
The employers are the problem
and they have the solutions.
Mark Duich
®
RS# 112
14
MACHINE DESIGN.com
MARCH 22, 2012
BERGQUIST HIGH-PERFORMANCE LIQUID GAP FILLERS
Bergquist’s
New Liquid
Gap Filler
Has All Your
Assembly
Angles
Covered.
Gap Filler1000SR (Two-Part) dispenses in-place without slumping,
offering you optimal flexibility in component orientation during assembly.
Gap Filler1000SR easily wets out under minimal pressure, The ideal thermal solution for automated dispensing.
giving fragile components superior thermal protection.
Unlike precured gap filling materials, liquid materials offer infinite
thickness options and eliminate the need for specific pad thicknesses
Gap Filler 1000SR is a two-component, room temperature cure,
or die-cut shapes. Available in cartridge or kit form, Gap Filler 1000SR
liquid-dispensable thermal interface material that features superb
is just one of many liquid filling solutions available. Whether for autoslump resistance.This material offers ultra precise dispensing, mainmated or manual dispensing, Bergquist has all your angles covered.
taining its shape on the target surface, offering you greater flexibility
in your component orientation during
Get your FREE Sample Card.
assembly. As cured, this soft elastomer
Take a closer look by getting your FREE Gap Filler
provides a thermal conductivity of
sample package today.
1.0 W/mK that is ideal for filling unique
Simply visit our web
and intricate air voids and gaps.The
site or call us
material flows easily under minimal
directly to qualify.
pressure resulting in little to no stress on Gap Filler 1000SR dispenses into position without slumping.With
fragile components during assembly. minimal pressure, flows in place with little or no stress on components.
Call 1.800.347.4572 or visit www.bergquistcompany.com/slumpfree
Request your FREE
GF1000SR Sample Card
and datasheet.
18930 West 78th Street 7 Chanhassen, MN 55317 7 A ISO 9001:2008 registered facility
(800) 347-4572 7 Phone (952) 835-2322 7 Fax (952) 835-0430 7 www.bergquistcompany.com
Thermal Materials
7
Thermal Substrates
RS# 113
7
Fans and Blowers
SCANNING FOR IDEAS
Edited by Stephen J. Mraz
Rugged
CNC
router
is
Cast-iron gantry
uprights have heavyduty gussets
easy to use
Precision ball
screw
Z axis
4-hp HSD high-frequency
collet spindle
Gantry
constructed of
tubular steel
THK guide rails
Tool-calibration
pad
Multizoned vacuumplenum table surface
Easy-to-use and
program hand
controller
Electronics housed in
NEMA-4 enclosure
All-steel
construction
Zones can be turned on and
off using these control valves
The HD Series CNC router from Techno
Inc., New Hyde Park, N.Y. (www.technocnc.
com), features solid construction with a
base frame made from heavy-duty tubular
steel that is welded, machined, and stress
relieved to ensure the base remains true
and steady over the machine’s life. The gantry is also made of tubular steel with reinforcing ribs welded throughout the length
of the column.
All electronics are housed in a doubledoored NEMA-4 enclosure. This lets technicians easily get into the cabinet to work on
power connections. The enclosure can also
serve as a work table.
The router uses several motors, including a 4-hp high-speed spindle drive, a
10 hp unit powering a rotary-vane vacuum
pump, and a series of brushless stepper
motors that serve as the machine drives.
The axes run on precision THK rails and
16
MACHINE DESIGN.com
MARCH 22, 2012
bearings for smooth, play-free motion. The
spindles use industry-standard ER collets
which are fully programmable from 6,000
to 18,000 rpm. The vacuum plenum table
is multizoned, letting operators switch
from full-sheet processing to smaller part
processing. Zones can be
For a feature on a CNC-driven plasma cutter,
turned on or off using conscan this code or go to:
trol valves on the front of
http://machinedesign.com/
the router. Gasketing can
article/cnc-plasma-cutteralso be routed to accommofrom-techno-inc-for-smalldate various material sizes
shops-0302
and styles.
Technicians can learn
how to install, set up, and
use the router by reading
a series of step-by-step manuals.
r
formation via ou
Request free in Web site at
Most machine functions can be
ice
rv
Se
er
Read
controlled through a user-friendly
sign.com/rsc
w.machinede
ww
handheld controller.
RS# 401
COMPLETE
ENGINEERING
#"#!" !
% "# "
(#!" !"#!
SOLUTIONS
Start here.
" ""!# " !
%""%%"
!!#!" '
#"# !"$& "!# #"'
*"#!!"#"!$!"!)
!# & "!!" "!"% "
HOW MAY WE HELP YOU TODAY?
TECHNICAL SUPPORT: 1.877.736.4835
COMMUNITY: element14.com
WEBSITE: newark.com
LEARN MORE: newark.com/together
RS# 114
SCANNING FOR IDEAS
Compressed gas
keeps
BD9JA6G>IN6I=6C9
circuits cool
Decentralized Servo Drives iX
offer unprecedented freedom
in mounting options:
Cover plate
Cavity spacer
Thermal load
<
¸On the Motor
<
¸On the Machine Frame
<In the Drive Cabinet
The Advantages for the
OEM are in plain sight:
Heat-transfer
plate
n EtherCAT and Sercos III
Gas inlet
and
outlet
n Continuous Power up to 5 kVA
n M23 Powerconnectors
(daisy chain)
n Reduced Wiring
n Functional Safety
n No Distribution Box
n No Hybrid Cabels
n Local I/O
n IP 65
18
RS# 115
MACHINE DESIGN.com
The thin-cavity fluidic heat
exchanger from Third Millennium
Engineering, Plano Tex. (www.
tmeplano.com), uses highvelocity gas flow to form a thin
boundary layer that keeps circuits
cool and isolated from possible
contaminants or EMI/RFI.
According to its developers, this
heat exchanger is technically
positioned between fans and heatsink methods of cooling, and waterbased cooling subsystems.
The device consists of a heattransfer plate, a cavity spacer,
cover plate, and a gas inlet and
outlet. Heat produced by circuitry
or any other thermal load is
conducted to the heat-transfer
plate, which can be flat, round, or
MARCH 22, 2012
any other shape. A gas, typically
compressed air, is sent into the
thin (0.01 to 0.001-in.) gap created
by the cavity spacer mounted
between the cover plate and heattransfer plate. Tests show that the
thinner the gap, the better the
cooling. And placing cooling fins
and channels in the gap make the
cooling device less efficient and
less reliable. The air carries the
heat away when it exits the cavity
through the outlet.
According to the developer, the
compressed air can be replaced
with nitrogen, oxygen, Freon, or
similar gases, and the gas can be
hot, cold, or room temperature.
RS# 402